Wednesday, September 18, 2013

Teach Kids About Hunger Through a Hunger Dinner

 
This was one of the most emotional experiences that I have ever had in teaching my boys about helping others, about the needs of others, and about what it is like to have need.  Several times during the evening of our Hunger Dinner, I found myself in tears, touched in ways that I had never imagined.  I know that my boys gained from this experience.  At the same time, I know that I gained more than I expected and most likely more than they did.
 
We live in an area where we don't see hunger on a daily basis.  We have been blessed as a family to not have to miss meals because of the lack of resources to buy food.
 
Helping others is something that we do each day.  My young boys (6 and 4 years old) are not unfamiliar with donating food, taking meals they made to people that need food, or talking about how to help others.  They know how to do that.  What they are unfamiliar with is boldly experiencing the inequality in resources . . . the situations where *they* go without when surrounded by others that have plenty.
 
Sure, being hungry is not fun . . . but what does hunger really feel like?  Sure, we can help someone . . . but what does it feel like to receive that help?  What does it feel like to help others when you know what pain they are experiencing?
 
When we read and discussed Uncle Willie and the Soup Kitchen a couple of weeks ago, we brainstormed ways that we wanted to help fight hunger.  One of the ideas we discussed was to have a Hunger Dinner, my own version of a Hunger Banquet.  (I first read about it last Spring in the book Kid's Guide to Hunger and Homelessness.   Oxfarm American Hunger Banquet has resources that you can download as well to learn more about a Hunger Banquet and access materials to host one.)
 
The Hunger Banquet is basically an experience to divide your dinner party up in the way that the world eats.  Some have a fancy meal, some eat a rice meal at the table, and some eat a rice meal on the floor.  The number of people in each group are represented by the percentages of people in those same situations around the world.
 
I suggested that we have a Hunger Dinner where 3 of our 4 family members would have a "rice meal" and one family member would get a "fancy meal."  Who got what meal would be decided by drawing a slip of paper . . . I explained this all to my boys.  They immediately pointed out that only one person would get a fancy dinner, which I confirmed.   And, after a few more questions, they decided to try it.
 
"You might not get a fancy meal," I tried to clarify.
"I know."
"What if you really want a fancy meal and you get rice?" I pushed a bit further.
"I like rice, and I'll just eat more food later if I get hungry."
 
The hunger was a topic of much discussion over the next couple days leading up to our own Hunger Dinner. 
  • Do kids only eat rice sometimes? 
  • What if they are really hungry? 
  • Why is it again that they can't find food? 
  • Don't their parents know how to get food from a store?
  • So, for how many days would they feel hungry?
The evening for our Hunger Dinner arrived with great anticipation.  The boys decided that the "fancy meal" for one would be at their favorite local hamburger joint.  I made the rice meals for three of us. 

We made the box and the slips of paper.  We rolled up the slips of paper with "rice meal" and "fancy meal" written on them.  I pretty much figured that there would be disappointment from the youngest child if he didn't get "fancy" and that we would work out how we were feeling as we were eating our food. 


When Dad FINALLY arrived home . . . the boys were in high anticipation about what would happen.  Even though Dad came home at the regular time, the boys were sure he was WAY LATE. 

We all sat down in the living room and talked about why we were doing this. The boys were antsy.  So, we jumped right in.
 
Dad went first. 

 
He got fancy.
 
The rest of us knew immediately what we would be getting.
 
Rice.
 
And then my oldest, the easy going child, looked like this.
 
 

 
And then, this.


He was in tears.  And, my Mommy Heart was breaking!  What had we done?  Was this lesson worth his disappointment, his sadness, his anger?  Was this the WORST experience we had EVER agreed to do in teaching our kids about the needs of others?

He was sobbing.

My easy-going, loving son was sobbing, almost uncontrollably.

And my heart was breaking.

Then, another surprise.
This one from Little Brother.

If you look at the picture above, you'll see Little Brother on the right.  Little Brother wasn't upset that he was going to have a non-fancy meal.  He was concerned about his big brother. 
 
Little Brother wanted to start helping to make it better for Big Brother. 
 
He offered his rice meal to Big Brother. 
 
He have Big Brother hugs. 
 
He got mad at me, the Mommy. 
 
He demanded fairness. 
He demanded that his brother have what he wanted, better food.
 
In all situations where there is need, we discuss how to help.  Dad stepped in, of his own volition, and offered to help.  Offered to share part of his fancy meal.  That changed the dynamics in the room.  I was no longer Enemy #1. 
 
In a moment of parental telepathy, Dad and I agreed that we needed to finish the Hunger Dinner.  We needed to eat our rice meals (and not easily skip over to the fancy meal, all holding hands in relief).  We needed to finish our experience and express gratitude for the food that we do have, even if it isn't fancy.
 
Little Brother more readily had his rice portion.  Big Brother was extremely reluctant. 
 
We talked about how we should be grateful for the food that we have, no matter how fancy it might be. 
 
We discussed that it could be any one of us that is the person that goes hungry.  We talked about the things that could happen to us that would result in us going hungry, not having enough money to buy food.  And, the boys listened.  Big Brother gave in a bit and ate his rice with less resistance, sort of.

At this point, I was not sure about this whole Hunger Dinner . . . the idea to experience it in this way.  Truly, we were not experiencing hunger.  None of us had gone without a meal or snack.  Each of us knew we had food in the pantry and fridge. 

After we finished our rice meals, Dad took us to the local hamburger joint and shared his fancy meal with us.  No more tears, no more angry demands that I make things fair.

I talked with Big Brother about what he was feeling.  I think that he was surprised to feel so angry about not pulling the "fancy meal" paper out of the box for himself.  He knew that could happen, and, yet, he felt mad and sad at actually experiencing the situation.  One thing to intellectualize an experience, another thing to actually live through the experience.

"I didn't like that."

"That was harder than I thought."

"It wasn't fair." 

"If we ever have to do that again, it needs to be more fair."  When I asked him about the kids that are hungry NOW, how do we made it fair for them?  He sat quietly and then said,"We do everything we can."

In a private moment, my husband and I talked together and shared how hard that was for us to experience.  I knew that I would be sharing this for the Moms Fighting Hunger Blog Hop.  How would I write it all up and still make sense?  And, then my husband said:

Can you imagine being parents where there is no handy "fancy meal" to share? 

Can you imagine the anguish for parents that cannot provide for their children?  How that must feel. 

How did your parents feel when they struggled with money when you were growing up?

Immediately, I felt as if I had run smack into a wall, forcing all the breath from my being.  And, I cried.  I cried with how desperate and powerless that would feel and the guilt that would come from feeling that I wasn't able to provide a basic necessity for my kids. 

I cried, feeling ashamed, because, for most of the evening, I felt like I had asked my boys to do something too hard.  In fact, I was asking them to learn a hard lesson, to imagine what it is like to be another, to develop empathy.  I was ashamed because *I* was uncomfortable in watching them in a very short-term state of discomfort.  They had the courage to be willing to try it.  Where was my courage in giving them space to be uncomfortable?  I don't know that I am articulating myself very well.  In all, I left the Hunger Dinner experience with wider eyes and a softer heart.

A week later:
I informally interviewed the boys about the Hunger Dinner.

Big Brother:  That was not fun.  We need to make things more fair for everyone.
Little Brother:  That was fun!
Me:  Why was it fun?
Little Brother:  I got to eat some fries.

(clearly, each boy has his own perspective)

Me:  What do you want to do now after our Hunger Dinner?
Little Brother:  (quietly) Serve people.  Help them.

We all can do something to help fight hunger in our community, in our nation, and globally.  The boys and I will continue to work with our local food pantry and learn more about hunger and how to help.  I will remember this lesson in empathy.

Here are helpful links:
Hunger Action Month
No Kid Hungry
Dine Out Week

Please join the Moms Fighting Hunger Facebook page.

14 comments:

  1. I know I've said before how impressed, inspired and moved I am by what you do, but I'm saying it again. Astounding. Your commitment, courage, bravery and dedication to change and service is a beautiful example. Thank you for being a part of Hunger Action Month and in such a meaningful way.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you for your efforts to unite so many people from so many places to combine efforts to make a difference. Participating in this has pushed my own thoughts and understandings in ways that I would not have predicted.

      Delete
  2. I'll be honest and please don't be upset with me, but this made me angry to read. I am one of those parents who struggled to put food on the table. My husband and would go without food so our girls would have more. I felt horrible telling them to drink more water when they were still hungry because I wanted our food to stretch longer. I feel this experience was sort of a slap in the face. I know you are trying to teach them about hunger but you reward them with fries. I wasn't able to do that, I was lucky to reward them with a second helping when I could. Try eating rice everyday for a week with no seconds and tell me how that goes. Please don't be upset with this comment, you said it yourself that you have been blessed with always having food. I am only trying to give you a perspective from a mother's point of view where meals have been skipped, where my kids know what hungry is. We are in a much better place now, and I hope you continue to serve others as this experience was intended to help with.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Dear Anonymous: Thank you for your comment. I am glad that your family is in a better place now. Sharing your perspective is important in all of us learning how to truly help others. Thank you for taking the risk to share with me some of what you experienced. Please know that this experience was not designed to cure anything but to teach my boys about being actionable to combat hunger (which was the purpose of sharing the “fancy meal”) and to create a greater awareness with others about the issues around hunger. As they get older, (they are 6 and 4 years old now) it will be more appropriate to help them understand the physical pain of hunger and then the other emotional aspects that are there as well. What you can’t know is my own experiences with hunger and poverty growing up because I didn’t share them. I wish that I could more directly correspond with you. You are unlikely to even see my response because it was posted as Anonymous. I wish you to know that your comment deepens the dialogue that so many need to have to truly understand hunger and effectively end it.

      Delete
  3. What a powerful lesson! I'm in tears from reading it. I love that you are so mission/ministry oriented and that you have a desire to teach your children to serve others even at a young age. Love running into like minded people--and our boys just turned 4 and 6 this summer!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You should know that your reflections and posts have, in such a short time, added value and pause for me. Thank you for your comment and look forward to learning more from you!

      Delete
  4. My favorite so far!! I cried reading the post. The cried reading anonymous's comment. I am drawn to vulnerability and this post was full of it.

    I smile that there are people like your family who care about the well being of others to the point of action. I call it compassion permanence, a compassion that doesn't go away when the situation is not in your face. This experience isn't just teaching your boys about understanding hunger. You are shaping their hearts in ways that will bless a lifetime of people.Good Job Mom!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. "Compassion permanence" . . . you are an expressive genius! TOTALLY going to use and push that phrase around in my mind. Thank you for your comment. Thank you for your own example in reaching out to others-- it pushes me to mold myself to be better. Today, we used a part of your Empathy through Role Playing, again--is one of our favorites!

      Delete
  5. This is anonymous again I just want to say thank you for your kind words and I am sorry I was upset which wasn't really towards you but at the situation and the feeling of helplessness. I am sure we have all been somewhere hard to be in our lives. We need more people in the world willing to help others out of the goodness of their hearts and to pass that message to future generations which is what you are doing, what I am doing, opening our hearts. Will be following you from now on.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Timmi-Words cannot express how grateful I am that you came back and reached out. You are an incredibly brave woman, and I am blessed to hear your perspective, as are many others. In fact, your comment furthered conversations in ways that were needed. We need your voice; we need your perspective.

      Delete
  6. This also put into perspective that the government CANNOT solve your problems as they preach. We were according them "making too much money" We were in our situation because we were behind in our house payments so we doubled up for 9 months to get caught up. These people don't care. Then a year later when my husband lost his job and we were able to qualify for food stamps I was disgusted by the amount given, which was more than $200 more than what I am used to budgeting for. We did not need that much, we know how to budget people in this country need to learn how to budget (I know its difficult when our leaders don't follow one). We were cut off that program immediately after his unemployment benefits went into affect 2 months later. They were barely enough to cover our bills. And we don't have tv, only one cell phone, no car payments, just house and utilities. That's it. It's still how we deal with life. Just the basics. I am so excited to have a garden next year since we will be able to become even more self-sufficient. We are also going to be getting a freezer for freezing and this summer I dipped my toe into canning. We need to not just give the fish, but to teach others how to fish.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Timmi-When I checked back on comments this evening, I noticed that my response to you here was lost. I am sorry about that. Definitely, the supports for welfare are a quagmire, to put it mildly. I am glad to hear that you figured out a way to weather difficulties and are still resiliently learning to be more and more self-reliant. I hope your gardening efforts go much better than mine. I seem to just feed insects, local bunnies & birds, as I figure out how to garden here. LOVE the freezer resource and canning can be fun and useful. (although I don't can as much as I should) And, your last statement is very poignant. Yes.

      Delete
  7. Just want to say what a moving post this is, and how brave you are to share. Sometimes activities to unexpected or are tackling such huge issues, it is hard to wrap it all up, but you did a great job. It was a wonderful idea too - and I'm sure your boys learned a lot :-)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you, Chelsea! I keep rewriting this post in my head, even today, several weeks later. It is about the process, the journey, for sure!

      Delete